Reality TV Island is the eleventh island released on Poptropica and is based on the hit reality TV show Survivor. The player has to compete in challenges against seven other computer generated characters, including antagonists from the first ten islands, to avoid being "voted off" a reality TV show called Reality TV Island. The computer generated characters all play exactly the same way, and any of them could beat you in some of the challenges. The island was released to Poptropica members on February 24, 2010 and was open to Non-Members on March 24, 2010.

The 14 challenges that come with Reality TV Island are: Balanced Diet, Boulder Push, Coconut Grab, Geyser Guess, Mountain Race, On the Line, Pole Climb, Shot Put, Shuffleboard, Turtle Shell Toss, Totem Hop, Water Run, Hang Gliding and Knockout.

The in-game description on the island is: "Have you ever wanted to be the star of a reality TV show? Well, now's your chance! Duke it out with your fellow contestants and avoid elimination to win the show's grand prize and become a hero to your hometown in the online virtual world, Reality TV Island."